Listing provided courtesy of Keller Williams Realty-MetropolitanCamille CraffeyMLS# 5083424MLS Provider
  • 60 days on site
  • 0 views

$150,000 price reduction, now offered at $1,350,000. Currently used as a short-term vacation rental, furnishings are negotiable. Bring your offer before the owners change their mind and pull it off the market for another ten years. Built in 1840, this Colonial with strong Gothic Revival influence offers a level of character that simply cannot be replicated after nearly two centuries of history. Original features include a brick fireplace with beehive oven, hand-hewn beams, a hidden vertical sliding stair door, pointed-arch wall niches, and Gothic Revival molding throughout, bringing depth and personality to the main house. A clawfoot tub with circular shower curtain, custom-built antique vanity, and a high tank toilet with pull chain preserve the integrity of an era that was both bold and sophisticated. A large sunroom connects to the kitchen with a pass-through window, allowing light to pour in from an entire wall of sliders. Step onto the balcony to watch the water glisten, or settle in beside the woodstove during a snowstorm. With 450 feet of frontage along Lake Todd in the no-wake zone, the property offers a calm, protected waterfront environment ideal for swimming, paddling, and enjoying local wildlife, along with your own private beach. Beyond the main residence, the property offers uncommon versatility. Unit two, a converted carriage house, includes a convenient mudroom, a large living room with hardwood floors, a private balcony, and a galley kitchen. Upstairs, there is a large bedroom, a bonus room perfect for an at home office, and a bathroom with a stand up shower. Unit three features an open concept kitchen connected to a large living room with a wood stove, along with one upstairs bedroom and bathroom. Both units are fully separate, offering strong income potential with it's established rental revenue, or multigenerational living while maintaining privacy. Please view property's 3D tour in additional links, plus drone video of property and grounds.

Source: Prime MLS, MLS#: 5083424

Love this property?
Create a profile so you can receive updates on this property as soon as they happen!
  • Property Type
    Residential
  • Lot
    1.20 acres

Get in Contact

Would you like to know more about this property? We're here to help! Let's connect and find what you're looking for.

ERA Key Realty Services

Create a profile so you can receive updates on this property as soon as they happen!

  • Median Age
    50
  • Population Density
    41
  • College Educated
    50%
  • Estimated Median Income
    $74,107
  • Estimated Total Home Owners
    765
  • Estimated Total Renters
    80
  • Owner / Renter Divide
    91% / 9%
  • Estimated Average Household Size
    2
  • Total Population
    1,922
  • Community data courtesy of LiveBy, Inc.

Owning this Home

$
$ %
%
* All calculations are estimates and provided by Reliance Network, for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary. ** Assumes 6.50% APR, 20% down payment, and conventional 30-year fixed rate first mortgage. Rates cited are for instructional purposes only; current rates are subject to change at any time without notice. You should not make any decisions based simply on the information provided. Additional required amounts such as taxes, insurance, homeowner association dues, assessments, mortgage insurance premiums, flood insurance or other such required payments should also be considered. Contact your mortgage company for current rates and additional information. Any mortgage broker or insurance agent that may appear is independent and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or provided by the MLS.

Life at 37 High Street


Schools


School data courtesy of LiveBy, Inc.
Ratings are based on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being the highest rating and 1 being the lowest rating. The schools displayed on this website are for informational purposes only and may not represent a complete or up-to-date list. School assignments are subject to change and should be verified directly with the local school district. Please contact the appropriate school district to confirm school zoning and enrollment eligibility for this property.

History

Date Event Value Agent
6/29/2026Source: Prime MLS Price Reduction
$1,350,000 -3.6%
5/1/2026Source: Prime MLS Added to Database
May 01, 2026